Fountainheadinvesting

Categories
Consumer Staples Stocks

Shopify (SHOP) Plummets 25% Post Earnings: Analyzing Valuation Concerns and Long-Term Growth Potential

Shopify (SHOP) $60 – Big 25% drop post earnings.

Shopify is still on the expensive side at 9x sales with 21% growth, and 63 x earnings with 35% growth. But it’s a lot cheaper after the drop.

What caused the drop, and does it change the long-term growth outlook?

  • Both revenue and earnings beat in small amounts.
  • Guidance was in line if you adjusted for the sale of the logistics business.

The drop was more valuation-related, which was high, and GAAP profitability has over the past year, become a sensitive issue with higher interest rates.

That said, the business is really, really solid – they’ve had two price increases (plus and premium tiers) with little churn from customers.

It does have Shopify has a significant competitive advantage in its dominant segment of SMBs –   in that it is the leader in small-to-medium-sized digital storefront provision of independent sites of access. The quality emphasis does resonate with customers who remain loyal.

I think it is worth accumulating on declines for the longer term- the only caveats being – that multiples are getting compressed and with Shopify’s relative maturity there will be scrutiny towards GAAP profitability, especially since their hyper-growth days are over. All that means that returns will be more sedate, but at this price, the downside is limited, with more upside potential.

Categories
Fintech

Pagaya Technologies (PGY) Update: $1.34 – Accumulating Between $1.25 and $1.35

Pagaya’s earnings call was a much happier experience and it did match expectations, with revenue and adjusted EBITDA being in line. 

The 2024 revenue forecast was in line with the $ 988 Mn V 1.04Bn expected; more importantly, this is more than 20% growth in revenue and volume. I expect the same growth from 2024 to 2025 as well since their new 2023 customers take two years to fully ramp up.

The biggest surprise was the adjusted EBITDA mid-point number of $170Mn for 2024. Pagaya had a run rate of $28Mn going into this quarter and I had modeled $123Mn for next year, a 20% gain, but this was more than excellent and a good sign that they are executing well. They are looking at GAAP levels of profitability from 2025-2026, the reverse split will be 12:1, and Q1-2024 reporting will be with the SEC under US GAAP standards. 

This was first recommended on 02/05, and if you need the details, let me know I can post it again.